Host: Mike the Apeman
1st Pick: Valerie Harper
2nd Pick: Dick Van Dyke
3rd Pick: Wilko Johnson
4th Pick: Tommy Chong
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Nick Stahl

Host: Shaggy
1st Pick: Zsa Zsa Gabor
2nd Pick: George Gaynes
3rd Pick: Alan Young
4th Pick: Kirk Douglas
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Edward Furlong

Producer: Colin (2 Points)
1st Pick: Louis Rainer
2nd Pick: Bob Hoskins
3rd Pick: Melinda Dillon
4th Pick: Bob Barker
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Justin Bieber

Producer: Nate
1st Pick: Olivia DeHaviland
2nd Pick: George HW Bush
3rd Pick: Billy Graham
4th Pick: Sen. Orin Hatch
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Lindsey Lohan

Name/Internet Handle: General Zod
1st Pick: Clint Eastwood
2nd Pick: Jerry Lewis
3rd Pick: Charlie Sheen
4th Pick: Tony Bennet
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Nick Lachey

Name/Internet Handle: Ryan Smith
1st Pick: Fidel Castro
2nd Pick: Nancy Reagan
3rd Pick: Geordie Howe
4th Pick: Kirk Douglas
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Chris Brown

Name/Internet Handle: The_Marshall
1st Pick: Gene Wilder
2nd Pick: Bill Cosby
3rd Pick: Robert Dinero
4th Pick: Nancy Ragen
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Shia Lebouf

Name/Internet Handle: Stefan (1 Point)
***FIRST STRIKE***
1st Pick: Ariel Sharon
2nd Pick: Michael Schumacher
3rd Pick: Howard Stern
4th Pick: Harrison Ford
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Miley Cyrus

Name/Internet Handle: Spyder "Commandant Stupid" Chiken
1st Pick: Sam Simon
2nd Pick: Valerie Harper
3rd Pick: O. J. Simpson
4th Pick: Wilko Johnson
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Justin Beiber

Name/Internet Handle: Eric Chiarolanzio (1 Point)
1st Pick: George HW Bush
2nd Pick: Mickey Rooney
3rd Pick: Abe Vigoda
4th Pick: Chevy Chase
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Ke$ha

Name/Internet Handle: PunchDrunkRambo
(1 Point)
1st Pick: Mickey Rooney
2nd Pick: Mel Brooks
3rd Pick: Zsa Zsa Gabor
4th Pick: Lindsay Lohan
5th Pick (surprise <= 40): Justin Bieber